• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • News
  • Events
  • Media
  • Video
  • Glossary
  • Contact
  • Download
  • RSS

Why the PC matters

June 18th, 2009  |  by jz  |  Published in Book, Future of the Internet, iran cyberwar  |  5 Comments

One less examined piece of what’s going on in Iran this week goes beyond the use of Twitter, Facebook, and other platforms — beyond what people can do with a basic browser.  And that’s the role of the humble PC — the personal computer, whether Windows, Mac, or GNU/Linux. What makes the PC so crucial is that it’s a “generative” technology, i.e. one that can be repurposed by its user at any time by simply installing new software.  Without it, those in Iran wanting to get to blocked information would be mostly restricted to visiting Web sites that aren’t blocked and hoping that they can connect to those that are — the way that Twitterfall can be used to tweet even if twitter.com is blocked, or visiting an anonymizer like anonymizer.com.

Of course, those can be blocked too, and often are.  Twitter’s ancillary sites are working — to the extent they still are — only because the censors have their hands full at the moment.  But the PC changes the equation on both sides: within and outside of Iran.

Inside Iran, people can load new software on their PCs to try to get around blocks.  Find a copy of something like the xB browser online, or modify your current browser to work with software like Tor, and you can try directing all your Web access through intermediaries that aren’t blocked.  If you find one that works, all your surfing can end up unblocked.  If people were using today’s mobile phones for Internet access instead of PCs, this wouldn’t be possible, because most mobile phones, even if they can hook up to a wireless Internet access point, won’t run outside code, or only run outside code approved by the vendor.  (The jury’s still out on how easily one can install outside code on a phone running Google’s Android OS.)

Even more important than the options available to someone inside Iran are the options for those everywhere else.  Many people have been eager to show support for those in Iran who want to evade the government clampdown on news, both in and out.  Thanks to the PC they can do more than color their personal avatars green.  If you have a PC and want to help, you can find instructions on how to download software that will turn your PC into a way station between Iranian citizens and the rest of the Net.  Two minutes ago you were playing Quake, and now you’re donating bandwidth and computing cycles to the free movement of bits — and you can even go back to playing Quake again.  And discussions are under way to reconfigure the just-released free Opera browser so it can serve as a proxy. [Update: Al Billings at Mozilla is thinking through the same questions for Firefox.]

That’s extraordinary.  The computing machines we buy are descendants of the old hobbyist machines of the 1980′s, which assumed people would get them so they could tinker with them, and those vestiges turn out to be crucial at a time like this.  We’re lucky to still have so many home PCs out there.  Our work ones are often locked down — your neighborhood IT department would have a heart attack if it found you running a proxy server, since it would worry about the security of the corporate intranet.  Most schools don’t allow their students to run new code in a computer cluster, and libraries are locked down, too.  (Indeed, all three of these places typically have their own content filters installed!)  Thanks to the PC, people can help forge new civic technologies — ones that succeed to the extent that people are willing to participate in them.

Perhaps soon we’ll see even more profound ways to transform access to the information grid.  Researchers have been puzzling through “wireless ad hoc mesh networking,” which allows devices to connect to each other without needing an Internet Service Provider to run interference.  If anyone is connected to the larger Internet, everyone else nearby — and everyone near everyone else nearby, etc. — can connect.  This is the method used by the One Laptop Per Child project to allow the PCs they are sending to kids in developing countries to share data with one another even if there’s no Internet drop point available.  Imagine that technology redeployed to this situation — and it can be, if someone writes or adapts the right software.  Our PCs have radios in them that can talk to one another, not just to an “official” access point; you may even recall seeing others’ computers in your wi-fi access list when trying to find a way to get online while on the road.  A little tweak here and there and it can start working — for school kids in Brazil, for hurricane refugees running laptops on battery power, and for citizens in Iran facing otherwise-limited Net access.

A green avatar is just the beginning — so long as we maintain our somewhat accidental ubiquitous infrastructure of generative, reprogrammable boxes, a legion of hackers ready to reprogram them to social ends, and a citizenry ready to donate some bandwidth and cycles to a good cause.

Responses

Feed
  1. Open Buddha » Blog Archive » So much for enabling freedom! says:

    June 18th, 2009 at 7:46 pm (#)

    [...] Zittrain has posted in relation to this matter as well. I seem to be timely as this just went up: Why the PC matters. This entry was posted on Thursday, June 18th, 2009 at 5:21 pm and is filed under Mozilla, [...]

  2. Seth Finkelstein says:

    June 19th, 2009 at 1:37 am (#)

    You already know this, but just for the audience:

    From my review of Access Denied:

    “if parents can limit what teenagers can see, then governments will be
    able to limit what citizens can see. And the other side is if citizens can circumvent governments, teenagers will be able to circumvent parents.”

    Pick one. Can’t have both.

  3. Andrew says:

    June 19th, 2009 at 4:55 am (#)

    Just a quick note that Tor has a completely configured, self-contained, 1-click way to use Tor now, called the Tor Browser Bundle. It includes an IM client, Firefox, and all the back-end plumbing you need to use Tor without having to configure anything. No need to “modify your current browser”.

    See https://torproject.org/torbrowser for more details.

  4. Computers can lead…a revolution-Jonathan Zittrain « FACT – Freedom Against Censorship Thailand says:

    June 20th, 2009 at 10:52 am (#)

    [...] 20-06-09 Why the PC matters [...]

  5. Andy says:

    June 20th, 2009 at 2:00 pm (#)

    In Europe Wireless Mesh is perceived as a very technical term but everyone knows Freifunk and the community associations of “having your own antenna”. In Berlin Wireless Mesh Networks are quite popular across the city as we have the Freifunk movement center here, it is real community work and it also shows why. Same in Italy. Patricia Toia wrote up a telecom spectrum bill for the Strasbourg European Parliament that was passed last year. Wireless mesh was in there. It was a great showcase to ge the OLPC project adopt Freifunk technologies. I remember the World Summit on the Information Society in Geneva where the internet access was plain crap, the OLPC project was kind of launched there. Freifunk looks like the natural thing to do with a wifi adapter.

    http://blog.freifunk.net/video

    http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=TA&language=EN&reference=P6-TA-2008-0451

Blog

  • Dropbox Ran Afoul of Apple’s App Store Review Guidelines: So What?
  • Last week, a number of developers reported that Apple was rejecting iOS applications that used Dropbox, a popular cloud file storage and backup system. An initial thread on the Dropbox developers’ forum has led to a outpouring of tech news full of hyperbolic claims. However, none of this reporting has covered the real problem – Apple is now more concerned about protecting its business model than serving its users or its developers.  Read more »

  • Help pioneer Casebook: The Next Generation
  • We at the H2O project are seeking a full-time Project Manager. H2O is an online platform for textbook development and distribution, currently in a pilot stage. H2O is based on the open source model – instead of locking down materials in formalized textbooks, we believe that course books can be free (as in free speech) for everyone to access and, equally important, build upon.

    Using H2O, professors can freely pull together materials for a course by selecting cases, editing those cases to the sections that are most relevant, and grouping them into readings. Once the materials are assembled, they can be copied in part or in whole by other interested faculty and then edited further.  H2O has been successfully piloted in JZ’s 1L Torts class, and will be rolling out further over the coming year.

    H2O’s project manager will play a leading role in shepherding H2O into its next phase, which will focus on developing new materials and incorporating additional features, in order to expand the platform beyond its law school roots.

    H2O is a  joint project of the Berkman Center for Internet & Society and the Harvard Law School library.  The Project Manager will be housed at the HLS Library and work in close collaboration with lead members of the Library Innovation Lab team; he/she will also work closely with the Berkman Center and current H2O teams. More info and job posting here.

  • Meme patrol: “When something online is free, you’re not the customer, you’re the product.”
  • I participated in the Berkman Center’s fascinating HyperPublic symposium in the summer of 2011.  When moderating a panel I invoked the aphorism that “When something online is free, you’re not the customer, you’re the product.”  It’s a way of encapsulating the idea that online free services usually make money by extracting lots of data from users — and then selling that data, or using it for targeted availability of those users for advertising, to advertisers.  In that sense, the advertisers are the clients, and the users enjoying free content are what’s being sold.  (Of course, sometimes that happens even when the user pays.)

    I didn’t coin the phrase, and since it was featured (and attributed to me!) in wordsmith.org’s wildly popular “word a day” as a thought for the day accompanying the word “enceinte” — I sought to nail down its provenance.

    The first use of the quote that we can find is as a comment within the famed MetaFilter community  in August 2010. The user’s name is blue_beetle, who might be someone named Andrew Lewis.  It’s entirely possible I saw it there, as MeFi is one of my five favorite sites on the Web.

    Similar sentiments (whether drawn from that source or independently invented) have been expressed by Bruce Schneier in October 2010 and by Douglas Rushkoff in September ’11.

    The phrase “you’re the product” also apparently appeared in a 1986 speech by President Reagan about the drug war.

    Just say know.

    –KA and JZ

  • OS X Mountain Lion and Gatekeeper
  • This week, Apple announced that it was moving to a new, faster OS X operating system development cycle, starting with the release of Mountain Lion next summer.  It previewed a number of features for the OS, and released some parts in beta.

    Mountain Lion is slated to include a feature called Gatekeeper as part of the security and privacy settings. Gatekeeper allows administrators (those with full privileges on a Mac) to limit the applications that can run on the Mac.  They can choose among allowing apps downloaded from the Mac App Store only, or apps from outside the Store so long as they are digitally signed to Apple’s satisfaction by their developers, or apps from anywhere.  (The latter has been the way both Mac and Windows PCs have worked, for better or worse, since the introduction of the Apple II in 1977.) Read more »

  • GPS-based Insurance Rates: The Devil is in the (Data) Details
  • A British insurance company called Motaquote has teamed up with TomTom, the GPS manufacturer to offer insurance prices based on data gathered by GPS. Fair Pay Insurance, Motaquote’s new program, is an opt-in insurance pricing scheme where drivers will get a free GPS unit in return for potentially lower (but possibly higher) premiums. The GPS unit will provide all the traditional navigational services as well as warn drivers when they corner too sharply or brake too hard. Read more »

About Jonathan Zittrain

jonathan zittrain

Jonathan Zittrain is Professor of Law at Harvard Law School and co-founder of the Berkman Center for Internet and Society at Harvard Law School

RSS Tweets from Z

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Blog Archives



Creative Commons BY-NC-SA Jonathan Zittrain unless otherwise noted.
Powered by WordPress using Gridline Lite.